Pain
I'm in College Park, Georgia, with Paula, visiting my parents. I've been using my brother's room a lot since we arrived Saturday night, nursing Paula there, having her nap there. We slept there a couple of nights, too, while Kit took the futon in the living room.
Casting about for something to read while nursing, I found Kit's stack of journals from the Association for Baha'i Studies. I expected the articles to be unbearably dry, but picked one up anyway. This is what I found, and this is why it has changed my life:
Love, Power and Justice, a talk by William S. Hatcher (abstract and publication information).
This amazing article talks about the quest for authentic human relationships as the meaning of life and the core of what it means to be happy. In it, Hatcher contrasts the way that Russian and U.S. cultures have confronted this quest. Simply put, Russian culture holds that true happiness is unattainable; life is simply one disillusionment after another and the only way to make it bearable is to choose friends who will share your pain. A good life is lived by nobly bearing up under that pain.
To contrast, American (U.S.) culture holds that happiness is truly attainable for everyone. It is not only a goal, but a right. However, a crucial aspect of authentic relationships, empathy for another's pain, is omitted from the equation in U.S. culture. The idea is that we can be happy without ever sharing another person's pain. Hence the fantasy worlds Americans enter through movies, video games, shopping malls, dance clubs and pornographic Web sites. This is what makes us able to know full well about the suffering of the many poor, homeless, abused and suffering people we come into contact with and hear about on the news, but not feel their pain. Happiness is our birthright, right? So avoidance is our modus operandi.
The article goes on to explore how to change society from one in which people seek power over each other through ideology, to one where justice and love are the norm. It is a truly awesome article that I wholeheartedly recommend you read. I'm going to ask my brother if I can take it home with me, or at least copy it. Please contact me if you want me to send you a copy. I think Mr. Hatcher will understand.
But this idea that American culture programs its members to avoid pain, particularly the pain of authentic interpersonal communion, is making me look at my life in a very different way.
If you've been reading this blog very long, you know that I have been struggling with issues of isolation in my parenting. I have a hard time being a loving mom to an unhappy baby when there are no other adults around. There's no use pretending otherwise.
I've been trying to think of how to change my life, how to change society, how to change the way I am in my community in order to remedy this problem. If I could just get a mother's helper to come over on those long afternoons of teething. If I could just have more friends close by. If I could just live near my sister. THEN the problem would be solved.
The problem isn't in me, I've maintained. I've figured it was normal to get tapped out after long hours alone with a baby. Everybody gets tapped out - why not me? What's the matter with trying to spend a little more time away from Paula? A little "Me" time? It's so tempting.
My sister-in-law Adele and my friend Angie have both offered me a different perspective that has been hard for me to grasp.
"Go into the relationship, not away from it," Adele told me over the phone recently. I had called for advice on how to handle Paula's recent extreme clinginess and the claustrophobia I felt. "Getting away from her will only make it worse in the long run."
"Our culture just doesn't support the idea of self sacrifice," Angie said over her kitchen counter the other day. "But that's what motherhood is about and it's one of the great gifts of motherhood."
They each have three children. As far as I can tell they are right on. What they say makes sense on a spiritual level. But when it's just me and Paula and she is zinging from happy to screaming to anxious to clingy, their advice crackles through the static in my head like a radio show from another country.
But it occurred to me today that maybe my problem is related to this American cultural trend away from empathy. Maybe that's what Adele means: go into the relationship, not away from it. Angie and self-sacrifice: it's about embracing the authentic relationship, the love and the pain.
I mean, why should I feel alone if there's another perfectly great human right there with me? It doesn't make sense. Especially since that human is flesh of my flesh, blood of my blood. If I have ever loved anyone, it's Paula. Why would I want to get away from her to feel less alone?
So today when she was very tired and I had bumped her head by accident against the car door frame, and tried to pee her but she didn't want to pee, and she just was falling apart right there on my lap, I felt myself unraveling, too. My patience, my inner peace, all disappearing through that damned trap door that always swings open at the worst moment imaginable.
But I took a breath and looked into Paula's eyes.
"I share your pain," I whispered to her.
She paused for a moment, then continued whimpering as I got her latched on and nursing. But I felt the trapdoor close, the peace return. I felt like myself again, holding my dear baby, the one person I've loved more than anyone since I loved my mother as a baby myself.
This is my new mothering mantra: baby, I share your pain.
feedback